Sunday, January 15, 2012

Advance Planning or Blind Panic?


One of the criticisms we, the voters, have of our politicians is that they tend to be rather myopic in their planning, rarely seeing beyond their statutory term in office. There have of course been three leaders during the last thirty years who have sought to leave a legacy and to some extent have done so to a greater or lesser degree: Mrs Thatcher, John Major and Tony Blair all looked beyond their time in office. In John Major's case he wanted to leave a railway system the nation could be proud of and I think it's fair to say, and most Conservative supporters I know agree, it was a disaster, both financially and unfortunately in the case of Potters Bar, quite literally. We now have a railway system where the only financial risk takers are the public who pay through high fares and even higher subsidies.

It was with this history of short-termism in mind that the announcement of the HS2 was greeted with such a lukewarm reaction this week by almost everybody except the editorial in The Times and by Estate Agents. The latter because for every five minutes saved on a rail journey to London house prices increase by 5%. We have proof of how that works in this area, once the Jubilee Extension had been completed and journey times via Waterloo to Gotham City had come down so house prices from Lymington, Brockenhurst and points in between up to Winchester started to rise.

I have to admit the announcement filled me with mixed emotions, the initial reaction was "Yes," we've actually decided to proceed with a major infrastructure programme that both Labour and Conservative parties have been keen to embrace since it was first talked about when the old King was still alive. My second and third reactions were, "Why?" and "How Much?"

The "Why?" was simply a gut reaction to the much trumpeted factoid that journey times from Birmingham to London, and presumably in the opposite direction as well unless, because Brum is further up the map, it really is uphill, by between 27 and 42 minutes which would somehow contribute to additional jobs being created. Apart from in the construction industry for the term of its building where would these additional jobs be created? Anybody who has ventured onto our railways recently, having first mortgaged their childrens kidneys, will be aware of the fact that anybody using the rail network for work begins work the moment they take their seat, presuming of course they can get one something I understand is rare of the line between Euston and Manchester. So where is this mythical time wasted whilst travelling?

The biggest concern of course is the cost. If you look at the small print it is quite evident that this is a vanity project to rival the Dome, something which has actually become a huge success since placed in private ownership. It is the Conservative's doing their bit for the green lobby, being seen to be investors in public services and showing the Lib Dems that they can be environmentally aware, and if it all goes tits up they can say it was Labour's idea in the first place. To get anywhere near the projected return on investment over its estimated useful life (hey, guess what I do for a living) is going to mean fares at eye watering levels which will mean that the only people able to support it will be those working in London. It will not empower Birmingham at all, it will make London even more powerful financially, there won't be any greater incentive to relocate to the Midlands because of HS2 than there has been to relocate to Ashford because of HS1. I'm not alone in my concerns about the financial implications, Allister Heath who comes from the other side of the political fence to me summed it up on Wednesday with his six reasons why it is a mistake.

It does seem slightly bizarre to me that having spent the last decade encouraging people to work from home, via improved Internet connectivity and tax breaks, that the Government of the day should be encouraging more people to travel to work by rail.

Of course going back to my initial reaction we should applaud the Government for taking this course but it does slightly smack of Blairism to me. The big gesture when really a lot of smaller gestures would work better although I think most people accept that the current railway system does not offer itself to simply being upgraded. Although it has to be said that in light of the public expenditure disasters that occurred on Labour's watch the estimated £10 billion spent on getting the scheme to the planning stage seems like small beer.

It is interesting to look back through the archives at how the whole plan was viewed when Labour were in power, just to make sure that people's opinions haven't changed wildly simply because of a reaction to the times, many of the financial and environmental concerns were noted two years ago.

10 comments:

Span Ows said...

I'm not convinced either and cannot see how the benefits get anywhere near making the time, effort and money worth it.

Paul said...

Good piece in the i on Friday about how nobody in London has made a fuss about losing their houses yet whilst the Chiltern people, who are getting a tunnel for all but two miles, have started protest groups.

Span Ows said...

...including Cameron's (step?) father in law!

A Northern Bloke said...

For me, it seems like putting £32bn worth of eggs into just one basket. At times this, it just doesn't seem like common sense.

Span Ows said...

"...But if there’s money to spare for building railways, what we need is low and medium-speed lines that go where we want to go, not bullet trains between big cities.
Our island is so small that a 125mph maximum is quite high enough.
The lunatic mistake of the Beeching cuts, which left dozens of medium-size towns without a station, needs to be reversed.
And perhaps above all, England needs a decent East-West link for both passengers and goods.


Read more: HERE

Unknown said...

Don't believe all the Nimby Rubbish! It's the press and the Government who dwell on the Chilterns all the time.http://www.uxbridgegazette.co.uk/2012/01/13/hs2-not-even-the-end-of-the-beginning-we-fight-on-113046-30118932/

oakleyses said...

michael kors outlet online, burberry outlet, coach outlet, coach outlet store online, nike air max, polo outlet, nike air max, kate spade, michael kors outlet online, ray ban sunglasses, tiffany jewelry, christian louboutin shoes, kate spade outlet, chanel handbags, tiffany and co, michael kors outlet, tory burch outlet, burberry handbags, ray ban sunglasses, longchamp outlet, replica watches, nike outlet, christian louboutin uk, longchamp outlet, coach outlet, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, longchamp outlet, christian louboutin, gucci handbags, coach purses, prada handbags, michael kors outlet online, true religion outlet, christian louboutin outlet, oakley sunglasses wholesale, oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet store, polo ralph lauren outlet online, prada outlet, nike free, jordan shoes

oakleyses said...

lululemon canada, jordan pas cher, nike tn, hollister uk, nike free uk, air max, louboutin pas cher, new balance, longchamp pas cher, abercrombie and fitch uk, nike air max uk, north face, hollister pas cher, ray ban uk, converse pas cher, guess pas cher, michael kors outlet, polo lacoste, ralph lauren uk, nike air max uk, hogan outlet, timberland pas cher, mulberry uk, true religion jeans, sac vanessa bruno, oakley pas cher, nike roshe, nike free run, sac hermes, burberry pas cher, michael kors pas cher, nike air max, ray ban pas cher, michael kors, true religion outlet, nike blazer pas cher, north face uk, true religion outlet, nike air force, sac longchamp pas cher, polo ralph lauren, vans pas cher

oakleyses said...

giuseppe zanotti outlet, herve leger, soccer jerseys, asics running shoes, ghd hair, lululemon, insanity workout, vans outlet, baseball bats, nfl jerseys, hollister, p90x workout, timberland boots, reebok outlet, hermes belt, north face outlet, abercrombie and fitch, mac cosmetics, iphone 6 cases, valentino shoes, oakley, chi flat iron, nike roshe run uk, nike air max, babyliss, nike roshe run, instyler, mcm handbags, nike trainers uk, nike huaraches, soccer shoes, beats by dre, bottega veneta, ferragamo shoes, new balance shoes, north face outlet, hollister clothing, jimmy choo outlet, longchamp uk, celine handbags, wedding dresses, mont blanc pens

oakleyses said...

ugg boots, pandora charms, thomas sabo, ralph lauren, toms shoes, lancel, nike air max, ugg uk, ugg boots, ugg, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, hollister, hollister, karen millen uk, louboutin, uggs on sale, juicy couture outlet, converse outlet, swarovski crystal, uggs outlet, links of london, montre pas cher, ray ban, ugg pas cher, gucci, wedding dresses, supra shoes, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, replica watches, coach outlet, converse, swarovski, vans, marc jacobs, pandora jewelry, pandora uk, juicy couture outlet, uggs outlet